Decoding the Forested Ecosystems of Western North America
Many people don’t understand the concept of Ecosystem Decoding. Maybe 1 in 10 actually gets it.

I have heard people say that historical information about forestry or logging operations, is historic, never coming back and belongs in a book on the shelf and has no bearing or relevance to the forests or forestry of today!!
Ecosystem Decoding is just using historical data, right? This is all covered in Historical Ecology and Historical Geography, right?
That is what some people think.
Ecosystem Decoding is way more than that and starts with Six Knowledge Streams.
Ecosystem Decoding is envisioned as encompassing information and data from the Four Knowledge Streams:
- 14,000 years of First Nations Traditional Ecological Knowledge
- Old Growth Forest Ecosystems (What I call Clean Code or Original Code or Baseline Code)
- Western Ecological Science
- How have we changed Forested Landscapes over the Past 180 Years under Colonial Forest and Fire Management?
But more than that, Ecosystem Decoding is and uses several levels and locations of data:
- Field Observations (Capturing Unrecorded Data such as Historic Post Harvesting Fires from Springboard Stumps with Fire Evidence)
- Field Measurements: Vegetation Species Composition, Structures, & Functions, Biological Legacies, Old Growth Characteristics, Ecological Processes, & Old Growthedness
- Field Observations & Measurements of Insects, Disease, & Decay on Trees and Logs
- Field Observations & Measurements of Tree & Plant Stress & Diebacks, Droughts, Windstorms, Snow Press, Root Rot Centers, & Individual Tree Deaths
- Field Observations & Measurements of Climate Change and Global Warming Impacts (Droughts, Soil Moisture, Tree & Vegetation Stress), Unusual and Uncharacteristic Growth Patterns, Adaptations, & Changes at Stand & Landscape Scales
- Office Information: Recent Records of Field Data (Silviculture Surveys, Timber Cruise), Harvesting, Silviculture Treatments, & Fires
- Office Information: Historic Records of Forestry, Logging, Fires, Salvage Logging, Tree Establishment, and Tree Growth
- Create a Continuum or Chronosequence of Data from Old Growth Ecosystems to Present Day
- Determine How Much The Current Ecosystem Before Us Has Moved Away from Historic Successional Pathways
- Determine What Successional Pathways the Ecosystem We See Before Us Is On
Composition, Structure, & Function
One of the overarching concepts and which guides measurements of forests and other ecosystems is by looking at the Composition, Structure, & Function of the ecosystem we see in front of us.
Not only must we understand the Composition, Structure, & Function of an ecosystem, we must also understand the connections, linkages, dependencies between each of the three features of this concept.
Composition
As a starting point we must understand the Composition of an ecosystem. This Composition could consist of the plants and animals of a forest, watershed, hillside, or landscape. Or equally as important, Composition could also refer to the seen and unseen ecological processes at work in a given ecosystem.
Composition could also include the a list of disturbance types to have impacted an area over the decades and centuries.
Or Composition could describe the dominant Forest Type on a Landscape such as Old Growth Forests or Second Growth Forests.
Composition could also describe the types of vegetation on the ground in the Herb Layer, or in the Shrub Layer, and the Tree Layer. For example, we could describe the composition of a Forest as mixed with equal amounts of Conifer and Deciduous Trees, and more specifically 25% Were Douglas-fir and 25% were Western Red Cedar, with 25% Big Leaf Maple and 25% Red Alder.
Composition could also describe the amounts and types of forests on a landscape: 90% Second Growth with 10% Old Growth with more detailed descriptions in a discussion of the The Matrix or Matrix Lands (See below).
Structure
An important part of the Composition, Structure, & Function concept is Structure.
All ecosystems are composed of vegetation in various sizes, ages, locations, stages of growth, decay, or death.
The vegetation types have various shapes, stem forms, and growth patterns.
The plants themselves have a specific structure or stem form that is unique to each vegetation species.
A group of vegetation structures can then form forest stands, riparian forests, hillside, and landscape locations.
When it comes to trees, these are the hard to miss, what I call structural elements of a forest stand or patch.
Trees as structural elements are often Large Old Trees, Trees of various sizes, heights, position in the forest canopy, and diameters, Dead Standing Trees or Snags of Various Sizes, Heights, and diameters, Stumps of various sizes to historic Old Growth to Small Second Growth, and Downed Trees or Logs.
These are the Structural Elements that Forest Ecology and Forestry are focused on, use the same language to describe them, but where they are such divergent views and understandings of their importance ecologically let alone economically.
In Forestry and Restoration, these Forest Structural Elements can be maintained, retained, or created so that they have a presence going forward and can act as Biological Legacies.
Function
The Ecological Functions of an ecosystem especially forested ecosystems are many and varied and depend on the Composition and Structure of the ecosystem.
In forested ecosystems, the Composition and Structures are integral parts of Ecosystem Functions and Ecological Processes.
For example, Large Dead Standing Trees or Snags are important and function as places to find food for birds like woodpeckers which chip away at the decaying bark and wood to find insects to eat.
As well, these same snags also provide habitat for woodpeckers if the correct species, the right amount of growth and size, and the right amount of decay is present to create a habitat possibility for a woodpecker.
But a tree has to be the correct height and diameter from the ground up, so that at the woodpeckers preferred height, the snag is of a sufficient diameter to be able to accommodate a nest to be excavated with enough solid wood to support the top of the tree above the next hole.
Tree growth and decay could take decades or even centuries to create the optimal woodpecker tree.
If trees are cut in commercial forestry operations before they reach this optimal age, height, diameter, and decay, then woodpeckers are likely to have little or no habitat, let alone developing habitat with new trees and then snags to provide habitat as older and more decayed snags fall to the ground.
Lifeboating
Lifeboating is the intentional maintenance or retention of the Biological Legacies that provide a patch or oasis of the former ecosystem that is forwarded to the future.
Natural Disturbances without intervention by humans, forward Biological Legacies to the future thus allowing a younger and ecologically recovering ecosystem to act like an more complex, older, and ecologically more advanced ecosystem sooner than later.
These remnant patches are literally like Lifeboats that safeguard the existence of life in the form of plants, structural elements, ecological processes, habitat, and sometimes animals that have survived and disturbance such as Wildfire.
Lifeboating allows these characteristics and features to be sent in their current form, and to become an ecological backbone and refugia from which the various plants and animals can spread back out into the ecosystem and aid in its Post Disturbance Recovery.
The Matrix or Matrix Lands
The matrix is the dominant forest type in a given area.
For example, 100 years ago, Old Growth was the dominant forest type and covered most of the landscape.
Today, Second Growth Forests that are 0 – 160 years old dominate many BC landscapes, while Old Growth Forests are now just scattered remnants of the spatial extent they used to cover just 100 years ago.
One hundred years ago, Old Growth Forests formed the Matrix while today Second Growth Forests form the Matrix.
When looking at restoring forested ecosystems we look at the Composition, Structure, and Function and the type and amount of the Matrix, to help determine the goals and objectives of our Restoration efforts.
We look at the all of these factors and our Ecosystem Decoding to determine what is missing in a given landscape.
We also look at historic Successional pathways and with our Ecosystem Decoding to see if our current landscape is:
- Following the historic successional pathway
- On a new or different successional pathway based on the types, frequencies, and intensities of historic disturbances
- If the historic or new successional pathways will provide Ecosystem Resilience in the face of Climate Change
The above paragraphs, summarizes fairly briefly my development, progression, and journey towards the development of Ecosystem Decoding
Ecosystem Decoding
- Field Observations of Patterns, Biological Legacies (Old Growth Trees, Snags, Patches, Logs), Composition, Structure, & Function (We Can Accomplish This)
- Field Measurements of Biology, Biological Legacies, & Patterns, Composition, Structure, & Function (We Can Accomplish This)
- Locate, Collect, & Analyze Historic Forestry, Logging, & Fire Data and Reports:
Pull out data on Biology, Patterns, Biological Legacies (Old Growth Trees, Snags, Patches, Logs), Composition, Structure, & Function (This Step Might Be Harder To Accomplish, So We May Have To Rely on Field Observations & Field Measurements Which Is Fine)
Field Observations & Field Measurements are the evidence of changes that the Historic Records would have pointed us to or confirmed.
Seeing Change
Seeing, recognizing, and recording change is hard to do, especially if you don’t know what to look for.
And when what you see now, looks normal and doesn’t look like it has changed in a major way or even changed a little, then the task is even harder.
Perhaps the scale of change is too small or too slow.
After all, time hasn’t stopped and trees are still growing.
I am often asked why an ecosystem looks a certain way and to describe the ways it has been changed or is changing.
Some Basic Observations to Record:
- Location Name (River, Road, Tenure, Ecosystem Name)
- Aspect: North, South, East, or West
- Elevation: in Meters
- Slope Position: Valley Bottom, Mid Mountain, Higher Mountain
- BioGeoClimatic Zone (in BC) or Describe the Ecosystem:
- Type of Ecosystem: Forest, Fire, Larger Wetland, Grassland, Avalanche Slide, Deciduous Forest, Plantation, Fresh Clearcut, Recent Fire, Riparian Forest, Oil & Gas Right of Way, Small Wetland, Swamp, Old Growth Forest
Some Basic Measurements
- Identify Different Vegetation Species using Plant ID Books, Seek (instant ID)/iNaturalist (Install in your smart phone)
- Visual Estimate of Percent Cover of Vegetation: Herbs on Ground, then Shrub Layer, & then Trees (Pretend your hovering in a drone)
- Heights of Vegetation Layers: Herbs on Ground, then Shrub Layer, & then Trees (One, Two, or All Three Layers May Be Blocking Sunlight Reaching Forest Floor)
- Crown Closure %: How Close are the Tree Crowns? How much Sky Do You See? Lots of Sky = Less Crown Closure, Much Less Sky = Much More Crown Closure
- Diameter of Trees (If you don't have calibrated Diameter Tape, measure Circumference and calculate Diameter from formula: Circumference/Π (Pi) = Dia (Pi x Diameter))
- https://www.google.com/search?q=circumference+to+diameter
- Amounts of Trees & Species of:
- Seedlings in Herb Layer Less Than 2 meters Tall
- Saplings Larger Than 2 meters Tall & Diameter 2 cm - 10 cm
- Bigger Trees More Than 2 Meters Tall & Diameter More Than 10 cm
- Are there Young Trees (Small Diameter & Shorter), Mature Trees (Larger Diameters & Taller, Old Trees (Big Diameters & Very Tall)
- Amounts & Species of Dead Trees (Snags):
- Snags Larger Than 2 meters Tall & Diameter 2 cm - 10 cm
- Snags More Than 2 Meters Tall & Diameter More Than 10 cm
- Amounts & Species of Downed Logs:
- Species: Look at Root End of Log for Shape (Species often have different growth shape of roots/lower stem) where stump is usually cut, Bark can often tell you what species the log is, or look at the stump (cut or natural) where the log came from
- Diameter at large end, 1.3 meters from large end
- Length
- Small Logs: 3 meters Long & Diameter 2 cm - 10 cm
- Larger Logs: More Than 3 meters long & Diameter More Than 10 cm
- Amounts & Species of Stumps:
- Low Stumps Mechanical Harvesting (Flat Top) 30 - 50 cm Tall
- Higher Stumps Cut by Chainsaw: 50 cm - 1 meter Tall
- Higher Stumps Cut by Axe & Saw & Springboard Notches More Than 1 Meter Tall
- Plot Radius for Measurements (Vegetation Data Collection, and Trees Live & Dead, & Logs, Number/Hectare = Species Composition %)
- 3.99 meter Radius = 200 Plot Multiplier Factor (If you count 8 trees in your plot = 8 x 200 = 1600 trees/hectare)
- 5.64 meter Radius = 100 Plot Multiplier Factor (If you count 8 trees in your plot = 8 x 100 = 800 trees/hectare)
- 11.28 meter Radius = 50 Plot Multiplier Factor (If you count 8 trees in your plot = 8 x 50 = 400 trees/hectare)
- Look for Evidence of Tree Deaths or Change, Insects, Disease, & Decay:
- One Tree (Insect or Disease), Several Trees (Root Rots), Many Trees (Windstorms)
- Look for Evidence of Previous Disturbances:
- Fire (Charcoaling) Trees, Logs, or Stumps, Soil
- Logging: Stumps & Logs (Cut on One or Two Ends)
- Wind
- Insects
- Decay
- Disease
- If there are NO Trees, then Non Tree Plants, the BEC Plant Indicators will Tell You About the Ecosystem
- Soil: Dig a Soil Pit & Look At:
- LFH (Litter (Forest Floor Lots of Recognizable Sticks), Fermentation (Less Recognizable Sticks & white Fungal Threads), & Humus (Dark Top Soil, No Recognizable Sticks))
- Ae or AH Horizon: Ae = Grey & Gritty, Ah = Humus (Dark Top Soil)
- B Horizon = Mineral Soil: Little or More Humus, Soil Type (Soil Triangle will help figure out
- Soil will tell you:
- Soil Richness & Growing Ability (Low, Medium, or High)
- Drainage (Slow (Clay), Medium (Silty/Sandy), Quick Draining (Sandy)
- Decode: Plant Indicators Species & Soil Attributes Will Tell You What the Ecosystem Is Capable Of, The Potential, and What Is Happening: Is the Ecosystem Staying The Way It Is, Or Is it Getting Wetter, or is it getting Drier?
The progression and evolution of Old Growth Science in the US Pacific Northwest and BC. Including the Implementation of Old Growth Scientific Knowledge in Forest Management:
1969 – 1979
US International Biological Program
Forest Biome: Old Growth Forests were studied for the First Time
1973
US Endangered Species Act (ESA)
May 1980 - Present
Volcanic Blast at Mount St Helens Washington
Living Laboratory: Biological Legacies, Threads of Continuity, Ecosystem Science, Post Disturbance Recovery
1981
Ecological Characteristics of an Old Growth Douglas-fir Forest
1984
BC First Nations Block MacMillan Bloedel from starting logging on Meares Island near Tofino BC
This was the start of the War in the Woods in BC that lasts until 1993 and the Mass Arrests at Clayoquot Sound
1985
Management of Wildlife and Fish Habitats in Forests of Western Oregon and Washington
Part 1 & 2
1989
Gang of Four Report to US Congress
scientific panel to develop recommendations regarding old-growth, owls and sustainable timber
supplies. Dr. Jack Ward Thomas, Dr. Jerry Franklin, Dr. Norm Johnson, and Dr. John Gordon
1990
A Richer Forest, Aguidebook for Sweden
1990
Thomas et al., Conservation of the Northern Spotted Owl
1990
Interagency Scientific Committee Report, US Gov
1991
Wildlife and Vegetation of Unmanaged Douglas-fir Forests
PNW GTR 285
1991
Conservation of Late Successional Forests and Aquatic Ecosystems, Johnson et al.
1993
Conservation of Species that Inhabit Late Successional & Riparian Areas, Thomas et al.
Mar 1993
Scientific Analysis Team, US Gov
Viability Assessments and Management Considerations for Species Associated with Late Successional and Old Growth Forests of the Pacific Northwest
Apr 1993
President Bill Clinton Pacific Northwest Forest Summit
Portland Oregon
Jul 1993
Forest Ecosystem Management Assessment Team (FEMAT)
Commissioned by President Bill Clinton
1994
Northwest Forest Plan for the Spotted Owl & Riparian Buffers for Salmon
1994
An Environmental Planning Guide for Finland
1993
Mass Protests & Arrests at Clayoquot Sound on Western Vancouver Island
This was the culmination of 10 Years of Battles on Logging Roads across Coastal BC from Clayoquot Sound to Haida Gwaii.
This spurred in a big way the 1994 BC Forest Practices Code & Guidebooks and big changes to the BC Forest Act.
1994
BC Forest Practices Code 1994 - 2004
Required the Retention of Representative Old Growth in every cutblock in Wildlife Tree Patches and Riparian Reserves
1995
BC Clayoquot Sound Scientific Panel Reports
Jerry Franklin and BC's Own Nancy Turner, Ethnobotanist were on Scientific Panel
1995 - 1996
Sierra Nevada Ecosystem Project (SNEP) in California's Sierra Nevada Mountains & the Giant Sequoia
Lead by Jerry Franklin
2002 - 2012
BC Coast Forest Conservation Initiative
In BC's Central and North Coasts, which are renamed as Great Bear Rainforest.
2016
Great Bear Rainforest Agreement to implement Ecosystem Based Management
Based on the work of Jerry Franklin, Andy MacKinnon from BC.
He has also worked and been involved with these Coastal BC First Nations:
1991 – 1994
Kyuquot First Nation
Managed and guided a forestry crew for the BC Ministry of Forests.
2023 – Present
Kwiakah First Nation
Advising on Regenerative Forestry Project that also includes, and is being led by, Suzanne Simard.
2025 – Present
Kyuquot and Checleseht First Nation
Advising on Ecological Thinning of 50–70-year-old second growth Hemlock stands with machinery.
2025 – Present
Kwakiutl First Nation
Sawmill Feasibility Assessment with Forest Inventory Assessment